Marketdash
Back to News

Credit Rejections Hit Record High As Lenders Pull Back And Trump Floats 50-Year Mortgages

MarketDash Editorial Team
10 days ago
Getting approved for credit is harder than it's been in a decade. Nearly one in four Americans are now being denied, with mortgage rejections hitting historic levels just as Trump's 50-year mortgage proposal enters the debate.

If you've applied for credit lately and gotten rejected, you're in growing company. Credit conditions are tightening across the country, and the numbers from the New York Federal Reserve tell a stark story that market commentator The Kobeissi Letter recently highlighted on X.

The overall rejection rate for credit applications has climbed to 24.8% over the past 12 months. That's the highest level since the Fed started tracking this data in 2014. Put another way, roughly one in four Americans who ask for credit are being told no. The rate has jumped 10.4 percentage points since February 2020, reflecting how dramatically lending standards have tightened since the pandemic era.

The surge in denials likely signals that banks are getting nervous about economic uncertainty. With inflation still elevated and tariff pressures mounting, lenders are tightening their criteria as household finances come under strain.

Housing Credit Gets Squeezed Hardest

The housing market is feeling the tightest squeeze. Mortgage refinance rejections have soared to 45.7%, marking a new all-time high. New mortgage application rejections hit 23.0%, the highest since 2015. So just as borrowing costs remain elevated, getting approved has become substantially harder.

Into this backdrop steps President Donald Trump's proposal for a 50-year mortgage, pitched as a potential solution to housing affordability challenges. The logic is straightforward: stretch payments over five decades instead of three, and monthly bills drop. But critics quickly point out the downsides. You'll pay significantly more interest over the life of the loan, and building equity becomes glacially slow when you're making tiny principal payments for years.

Auto Loans And Credit Cards Also Tightening

It's not just mortgages. Auto loan rejection rates increased to 15.2%, the second-highest level on record, as lenders grow more cautious about elevated monthly payments and borrower creditworthiness. Credit card rejection rates held steady at 21.2%, but that's still historically high, indicating that consumer credit availability has broadly contracted.

Here's where things get interesting though. While private lenders are pulling back, federal housing agencies are moving in the opposite direction. Fannie Mae recently removed its minimum credit score requirement for most loans processed through its automated underwriting system. Freddie Mac has expanded approvals for borrowers without traditional credit scores by accepting verified rent, utility, and other payment histories. Regulators have also authorized both agencies to adopt newer scoring models that incorporate trended data and alternative payment information.

So we're in this unusual moment where everyday lenders are slamming doors shut while government-backed entities are opening new pathways. Whether that divergence helps or hurts the housing market long-term remains to be seen.

Back to News

Credit Rejections Hit Record High As Lenders Pull Back And Trump Floats 50-Year Mortgages

MarketDash Editorial Team
10 days ago
Getting approved for credit is harder than it's been in a decade. Nearly one in four Americans are now being denied, with mortgage rejections hitting historic levels just as Trump's 50-year mortgage proposal enters the debate.

If you've applied for credit lately and gotten rejected, you're in growing company. Credit conditions are tightening across the country, and the numbers from the New York Federal Reserve tell a stark story that market commentator The Kobeissi Letter recently highlighted on X.

The overall rejection rate for credit applications has climbed to 24.8% over the past 12 months. That's the highest level since the Fed started tracking this data in 2014. Put another way, roughly one in four Americans who ask for credit are being told no. The rate has jumped 10.4 percentage points since February 2020, reflecting how dramatically lending standards have tightened since the pandemic era.

The surge in denials likely signals that banks are getting nervous about economic uncertainty. With inflation still elevated and tariff pressures mounting, lenders are tightening their criteria as household finances come under strain.

Housing Credit Gets Squeezed Hardest

The housing market is feeling the tightest squeeze. Mortgage refinance rejections have soared to 45.7%, marking a new all-time high. New mortgage application rejections hit 23.0%, the highest since 2015. So just as borrowing costs remain elevated, getting approved has become substantially harder.

Into this backdrop steps President Donald Trump's proposal for a 50-year mortgage, pitched as a potential solution to housing affordability challenges. The logic is straightforward: stretch payments over five decades instead of three, and monthly bills drop. But critics quickly point out the downsides. You'll pay significantly more interest over the life of the loan, and building equity becomes glacially slow when you're making tiny principal payments for years.

Auto Loans And Credit Cards Also Tightening

It's not just mortgages. Auto loan rejection rates increased to 15.2%, the second-highest level on record, as lenders grow more cautious about elevated monthly payments and borrower creditworthiness. Credit card rejection rates held steady at 21.2%, but that's still historically high, indicating that consumer credit availability has broadly contracted.

Here's where things get interesting though. While private lenders are pulling back, federal housing agencies are moving in the opposite direction. Fannie Mae recently removed its minimum credit score requirement for most loans processed through its automated underwriting system. Freddie Mac has expanded approvals for borrowers without traditional credit scores by accepting verified rent, utility, and other payment histories. Regulators have also authorized both agencies to adopt newer scoring models that incorporate trended data and alternative payment information.

So we're in this unusual moment where everyday lenders are slamming doors shut while government-backed entities are opening new pathways. Whether that divergence helps or hurts the housing market long-term remains to be seen.