Marketdash
Back to News

Jobs Report Sparks Fierce Debate: Is the Labor Market Cooling Down or Breaking Down?

MarketDash Editorial Team
7 hours ago
November's delayed jobs data didn't settle anything. Instead, it deepened the rift among Wall Street economists over whether the U.S. labor market is experiencing a healthy slowdown or the start of something worse.

If you were hoping November's delayed jobs report would finally answer the big question about where the labor market is headed, well, you're going to be disappointed. Instead of clarity, we got more ammunition for both sides of an increasingly heated debate among economists: is the U.S. labor market cooling off in a manageable way, or is it quietly cracking?

It's a simple question with enormous consequences. Because if it's just cooling, the Federal Reserve can take its time and stay patient. But if it's starting to crack, policymakers might already be dangerously behind.

Government Shutdown Makes Everything Messy

The Bureau of Labor Statistics data dropped Tuesday, and here's what we got: October saw payrolls drop by 105,000 jobs, but nearly all of that decline came from 157,000 government layoffs tied to the shutdown. Strip out the government chaos, and the private sector actually added 52,000 jobs that month.

November looked better on the surface. Government payrolls stabilized, private-sector hiring picked up to 69,000, and total payroll growth landed at 64,000 jobs. That beat expectations slightly, but it's still nowhere near the robust numbers you'd expect from a healthy, expanding economy.

Then there are the revisions, which didn't help matters. August got revised down by 22,000 jobs, moving from a loss of 4,000 to a loss of 26,000. September took an 11,000-job haircut, landing at 108,000. The cooling trend is real, even if the exact temperature is hard to pin down.

But the household survey data? That's where things get really interesting. The unemployment rate jumped to 4.6% in November, up from 4.4% in September. That's the highest level since September 2021, and it's got people paying attention.

For some economists, this is all still within normal parameters. The labor market is steady enough for the Fed to keep rates where they are and wait things out. For others, though, rising unemployment combined with slowing job growth is a flashing warning sign. They argue the Fed needs to cut rates again as soon as January, even though market pricing suggests traders aren't expecting that.

The Optimists: No Need to Panic Yet

"Taken together, the October-November jobs data don't change our view that the labor market is steady enough for the Federal Reserve to keep policy on hold until mid-2026," said Nancy Vanden Houten, lead U.S. economist at Oxford Economics.

She pointed out that both months delivered healthy private payroll gains, and the November headline number looked stronger mainly because government job losses hit in October rather than being spread out. In other words, it's a timing quirk, not a fundamental shift.

Vanden Houten also warned against reading too much into the unemployment spike. The Bureau of Labor Statistics couldn't conduct its household survey in October, which complicated November's data collection. Plus, the number of permanent job losers actually declined in November, and some of the unemployment rate increase came from labor force growth, which is generally a positive sign.

David Russell, global head of market strategy at TradeStation, agrees that higher unemployment doesn't automatically mean the economy is weakening.

"Higher unemployment might seem dovish for rates," Russell said. "However, it resulted from government job cuts and not weakness in the cyclical economy." He highlighted a longer-than-expected workweek and healthy retail sales as evidence that demand is holding up fine.

According to Russell, the report doesn't really change the Fed's path after three rate cuts this year, especially with fiscal stimulus expected to keep growth supported.

The Pessimists: Cracks Are Forming and the Fed Needs to Act

Not everyone is buying the optimistic take.

Heather Long, chief economist at Navy Federal Credit Union, described what we're seeing as a "hiring recession." Job growth has essentially flatlined since April, she noted. Payroll gains since May have been modest and inconsistent, while wage growth keeps slowing down.

"Almost no jobs have been added since April," Long said, pointing out that there are now 710,000 more unemployed Americans than there were in November 2024. She blamed a combination of tariff impacts, artificial intelligence adoption, and aggressive corporate cost-cutting for the weakness.

Mohamed El-Erian, chief economic advisor at Allianz, also pushed back against dismissing the report as just noise. Yes, there are shutdown-related distortions, he acknowledged. But if you had to pick a direction, the data points toward a weakening labor market, and that "warns against an extended Fed rate pause."

"The latest jobs data pressure the Fed to cut rates again when they next meet in January. Hiring momentum has weakened in recent months, and the Fed will want to arrest this deterioration and help labor demand regain traction," said Bill Adams, chief economist for Comerica Bank.

Comerica is now going against market consensus, forecasting a quarter-point rate cut at the Fed's January 28 meeting. CME FedWatch currently shows only a 30% probability priced in for that outcome, so they're taking a contrarian stance.

Charlie Bilello, chief market strategist at Creative Planning, delivered perhaps the starkest warning. Total U.S. job growth over the past year has slowed to just 0.6%, the weakest pace since March 2021.

"In the past 50 years, this type of weakness in the labor market has preceded a recession and a spike in the unemployment rate 100% of the time," Bilello said. That's a perfect historical track record, which makes it hard to ignore.

Markets React with Caution

Wall Street didn't exactly celebrate the jobs data. Major stock indexes dipped lower in early trading as investors tried to make sense of the mixed signals.

The S&P 500, tracked by the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO), slipped 0.3% to 6,790, marking its third consecutive session of losses.

Meanwhile, gold continued its recent rally as economic uncertainty drove investors toward safe havens. Bullion prices, tracked by the SPDR Gold Shares (GLD), climbed 0.5% to $4,320 an ounce, staying close to the record highs near $4,250 set back in October.

So where does that leave us? With the same question we started with, unfortunately. The labor market is definitely slowing down. Whether that's a controlled cooldown or the beginning of a breakdown depends entirely on which economist you ask. And with the Fed's next meeting coming up in January, we'll find out soon enough which camp Jerome Powell and his colleagues find more convincing.

Back to News

Jobs Report Sparks Fierce Debate: Is the Labor Market Cooling Down or Breaking Down?

MarketDash Editorial Team
7 hours ago
November's delayed jobs data didn't settle anything. Instead, it deepened the rift among Wall Street economists over whether the U.S. labor market is experiencing a healthy slowdown or the start of something worse.

If you were hoping November's delayed jobs report would finally answer the big question about where the labor market is headed, well, you're going to be disappointed. Instead of clarity, we got more ammunition for both sides of an increasingly heated debate among economists: is the U.S. labor market cooling off in a manageable way, or is it quietly cracking?

It's a simple question with enormous consequences. Because if it's just cooling, the Federal Reserve can take its time and stay patient. But if it's starting to crack, policymakers might already be dangerously behind.

Government Shutdown Makes Everything Messy

The Bureau of Labor Statistics data dropped Tuesday, and here's what we got: October saw payrolls drop by 105,000 jobs, but nearly all of that decline came from 157,000 government layoffs tied to the shutdown. Strip out the government chaos, and the private sector actually added 52,000 jobs that month.

November looked better on the surface. Government payrolls stabilized, private-sector hiring picked up to 69,000, and total payroll growth landed at 64,000 jobs. That beat expectations slightly, but it's still nowhere near the robust numbers you'd expect from a healthy, expanding economy.

Then there are the revisions, which didn't help matters. August got revised down by 22,000 jobs, moving from a loss of 4,000 to a loss of 26,000. September took an 11,000-job haircut, landing at 108,000. The cooling trend is real, even if the exact temperature is hard to pin down.

But the household survey data? That's where things get really interesting. The unemployment rate jumped to 4.6% in November, up from 4.4% in September. That's the highest level since September 2021, and it's got people paying attention.

For some economists, this is all still within normal parameters. The labor market is steady enough for the Fed to keep rates where they are and wait things out. For others, though, rising unemployment combined with slowing job growth is a flashing warning sign. They argue the Fed needs to cut rates again as soon as January, even though market pricing suggests traders aren't expecting that.

The Optimists: No Need to Panic Yet

"Taken together, the October-November jobs data don't change our view that the labor market is steady enough for the Federal Reserve to keep policy on hold until mid-2026," said Nancy Vanden Houten, lead U.S. economist at Oxford Economics.

She pointed out that both months delivered healthy private payroll gains, and the November headline number looked stronger mainly because government job losses hit in October rather than being spread out. In other words, it's a timing quirk, not a fundamental shift.

Vanden Houten also warned against reading too much into the unemployment spike. The Bureau of Labor Statistics couldn't conduct its household survey in October, which complicated November's data collection. Plus, the number of permanent job losers actually declined in November, and some of the unemployment rate increase came from labor force growth, which is generally a positive sign.

David Russell, global head of market strategy at TradeStation, agrees that higher unemployment doesn't automatically mean the economy is weakening.

"Higher unemployment might seem dovish for rates," Russell said. "However, it resulted from government job cuts and not weakness in the cyclical economy." He highlighted a longer-than-expected workweek and healthy retail sales as evidence that demand is holding up fine.

According to Russell, the report doesn't really change the Fed's path after three rate cuts this year, especially with fiscal stimulus expected to keep growth supported.

The Pessimists: Cracks Are Forming and the Fed Needs to Act

Not everyone is buying the optimistic take.

Heather Long, chief economist at Navy Federal Credit Union, described what we're seeing as a "hiring recession." Job growth has essentially flatlined since April, she noted. Payroll gains since May have been modest and inconsistent, while wage growth keeps slowing down.

"Almost no jobs have been added since April," Long said, pointing out that there are now 710,000 more unemployed Americans than there were in November 2024. She blamed a combination of tariff impacts, artificial intelligence adoption, and aggressive corporate cost-cutting for the weakness.

Mohamed El-Erian, chief economic advisor at Allianz, also pushed back against dismissing the report as just noise. Yes, there are shutdown-related distortions, he acknowledged. But if you had to pick a direction, the data points toward a weakening labor market, and that "warns against an extended Fed rate pause."

"The latest jobs data pressure the Fed to cut rates again when they next meet in January. Hiring momentum has weakened in recent months, and the Fed will want to arrest this deterioration and help labor demand regain traction," said Bill Adams, chief economist for Comerica Bank.

Comerica is now going against market consensus, forecasting a quarter-point rate cut at the Fed's January 28 meeting. CME FedWatch currently shows only a 30% probability priced in for that outcome, so they're taking a contrarian stance.

Charlie Bilello, chief market strategist at Creative Planning, delivered perhaps the starkest warning. Total U.S. job growth over the past year has slowed to just 0.6%, the weakest pace since March 2021.

"In the past 50 years, this type of weakness in the labor market has preceded a recession and a spike in the unemployment rate 100% of the time," Bilello said. That's a perfect historical track record, which makes it hard to ignore.

Markets React with Caution

Wall Street didn't exactly celebrate the jobs data. Major stock indexes dipped lower in early trading as investors tried to make sense of the mixed signals.

The S&P 500, tracked by the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO), slipped 0.3% to 6,790, marking its third consecutive session of losses.

Meanwhile, gold continued its recent rally as economic uncertainty drove investors toward safe havens. Bullion prices, tracked by the SPDR Gold Shares (GLD), climbed 0.5% to $4,320 an ounce, staying close to the record highs near $4,250 set back in October.

So where does that leave us? With the same question we started with, unfortunately. The labor market is definitely slowing down. Whether that's a controlled cooldown or the beginning of a breakdown depends entirely on which economist you ask. And with the Fed's next meeting coming up in January, we'll find out soon enough which camp Jerome Powell and his colleagues find more convincing.

    Jobs Report Sparks Fierce Debate: Is the Labor Market Cooling Down or Breaking Down? - MarketDash News