Sometimes the market gets what it wants and still doesn't know what to do with it. That was Tuesday's vibe as investors sorted through a labor market report that checked multiple boxes while raising new questions about where the economy is headed.

The CNN Money Fear and Greed Index captured the mood pretty well, dropping from 52.3 to 46.6 and sliding into neutral territory. It's the kind of reading that screams "we're thinking about it" rather than panic or euphoria.

U.S. stocks closed mixed on Monday, with the Dow Jones taking the biggest hit—down 302 points to settle at 48,114.26. The data driving the selloff? November's jobs report delivered 64,000 new nonfarm payrolls, actually topping the 50,000 economists expected. But here's the catch: the unemployment rate jumped to 4.6%, marking the highest level since September 2021.

It's the kind of mixed signal that makes traders squint at their screens. Enough job creation to suggest the economy isn't cratering, but rising unemployment that hints at cracks forming beneath the surface.

Federal Reserve watchers didn't budge much on their expectations. Fed funds futures still priced in just a 25% chance of another 25-basis-point rate cut in January, essentially unchanged from before the data dropped. The market is saying: interesting, but not game-changing.

The economic data pile kept growing. October retail sales came in completely flat compared to September, missing the 0.1% growth estimate and sliding from a revised 0.1% gain the previous month. Meanwhile, the S&P Global flash composite PMI fell to 53 in December from 54.2 in November, hitting its lowest reading in six months.

Sector performance told the tale of a market searching for direction. Most S&P 500 sectors closed in the red, with energy, healthcare, and real estate taking the hardest hits. But consumer discretionary and information technology stocks pushed against the tide, finishing higher and helping the Nasdaq Composite eke out a 0.23% gain to close at 23,111.46. The S&P 500 split the difference, dropping 0.24% to 6,800.26.

Looking ahead, investors have their calendars marked for earnings reports from Jabil Inc. (JBL), General Mills Inc. (GIS), and Micron Technology Inc. (MU).

Understanding the Fear and Greed Index

So what exactly is this Fear and Greed Index everyone keeps mentioning? Think of it as Wall Street's mood ring. The premise is straightforward: fear pushes stock prices down, greed pushes them up. The index crunches seven equal-weighted indicators to spit out a number between 0 and 100, where 0 means everyone's hiding under their desks and 100 means they're throwing caution out the window.

At 46.6, Tuesday's reading landed squarely in neutral territory—not scared, not euphoric, just...waiting to see what happens next.